Wirehead Studios

General Discussion => Entertainment => Topic started by: Phoenix on 2006-09-01, 02:02



Title: Classic Trek Redone?
Post by: Phoenix on 2006-09-01, 02:02
http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=24344 (http://www.aintitcool.com/display.cgi?id=24344)

So now you can see it both ways - the original series on DVD, or this updated version with the new special effects and remastering.  I'm still a bit miffed over the DVD release of Star Trek:  The Motion Picture not being available in the Special Longer Version I have on VHS.  I liked that version the best, and I did not like the changes done to the Motion Picture DVD release:  eg, the computer voice, the ship alarm, the V-GER exterior shots.  I always liked the fact that you never got to see the whole thing from a long-range exterior.  It took away that sense of mass when they did the DVD.  I know that's what the director wanted, but cinematically it lost something with the updated effects.

Regarding the series, I think this is going to be a bit less revisionist than what Lucas did with Star Wars, but I'm curious to see if they bollocks the whole thing up, or if the new effects add to the series at all.


Title: Re: Classic Trek Redone?
Post by: scalliano on 2006-09-02, 02:21
Not having seen the DVD version of the Motion Picture, I can't comment on that, but if the Star Wars special editions are anything to go by, this could be a very mixed bag indeed. My main issue with the SW updates was that certain scenes I (personally) would have expected to be remixed were completely left alone, resulting in visuals which ping-ponged between utterly stunning and utterly crap. Thing is, they didn't seem as crap in the original editions ...