That link works good - thanks.

Personally, those blue skulls on the walls just do not look right... I'd replace them with some sort of decorative banister.

I also think that this map should be submitted to mapping forums for more in-depth criticism:

http://www.map-center.com/
http://www.levelsource.com/

Not only will you get sound technical advice from experienced mappers, but it will also help put the spotlight on Generations to the quake community =D

Well thank you, it is close to finished, hope  we can throw a Wolfy home frag party when its done and you can join us!  :=)  

Right i've been playing your map abit and i found some issues, tho at the momment i can't upload those screenshots anyware..i'll see if there is a way for me to get em to you.

first impressions: Layout is good maybe it is a bit flat but that what a wolf map should be! it  do have a somewhat lack of details the textures repeat quite often but once again to make a classic wolf map they just.. "feel" right! some areas in this map i just love especially the hitler quad..hehe

anyways you know the "swatsika" (damn i can't spell it right) ceiling you have used a curve and next to the curve brush i noticed you used standard brushes some of these are clipped wrong i can see an edge on four of these. i recommend instead of clipping brushes skew them! use the brush editing tool (E key)

and since we are in that room i also sometimes get sparklies on those pillars (green/blue texture)  have you run the brush clean up tool?  i suggest you just remake those pillars since it's quite easy.

Your r_speeds are quite ok and im gonna go in on something that in this case aint important at all but could be nice to know eh?
Your doors doesnt block visibility at all, yes a normal door doesnt do this but there is this nifty little thing called Area portal! you'll find it under the common textures  if you place a small brush painted with this texture in a correct way the door should now block vis once it's closed..
However to get this to work right aint that easy as it sounds some serious reading in the radiant manual is required and a bit of luck

Now you don't have to bother about this since your r_speeds are low! but just a thought since you do have many doors on this map

Next thing: may i ask how you make your end caps?
For me it looks like you are using two square cylinder brushes to create one arch way?  There is a good thing about square cylinders and that is that they never "crack" but getting those textures lined up in a proper way is usually a pain and i've noticed several places where your textures are mis aligned.

Maybe you should try to create either: two bevel brushes and using a simple patch mesh as an "cap" or use one end cap curve brush + simple patch mesh?

if you get cracks with those you could, instead of using two square (if you are doing that) cylinders just use one.

Also before you realease this map i suggest you should try to play it online with some ppls! that's the best way to find out if the item placment is good enough!

I also whould like to know which options you use with q3map2
Now i think i've talked here enough hehe so keep up the good work man!!! your insane mapping speed is incredible! you impress me!

/ReBoOt

Im gonna try to get u those screens..it's easier to explain then. I'll see what i can do about that..

And sparklies is teh evil... i hate them btw  those pillars aint "splitted" in anyway? they are just in one piece? are they detailed?

Come to think about it i had a problem when i created that large pillar in my q2dm5 remake.
I got this tiny almost invisible line between each face...it's like they where clipped in a strange way but it was only one brush!!
But instead of just using one brush i used several and..poof the problem was gone..i still don't know what caused this

Well If you don't want those archways to be to curvy why not use standard brushes? then u don't have to worry about misaligned textures? man i sometimes wonder what ID thought about when they did the "curves".... the problem with square cylinders is that if you want something to aligned properly you have to for eg. use "natural" inside the "bevel" part or else it will look strange, and use "cap" for the sides.

You can only do one thing on square cylinders and that sucks..that's why i never use them unless i have to. simple patch mesh is your friend..mostly until you get a curve crack

To be honest making a map to gen is a bitch..it is hard to balance it for each class.. and even if you think you got it right some class will always have an advantage over another...and then pho comes with a code change.. J/K

heh i wonder if it has gone too far if you starts to notice the diffrence between -super 2 and -samples  oh well

Well feedback is for me very important , well "good" feedback that is if someone just says: this and that sucks doesnt help much i hope i gave you a some what good feedback!
I do want to play good and fun maps too, which i do think this map will be!
 Also im amazed you can make these maps so quick

*Edit man do i use way to many smileys or what? scary....*

Uhmmm  as much as I try I can't see any sparklies at all anywhere on the map, I had'em a lot but I had fixed them, I can't seem to see thru any of the columns either at any seams, what settings do you play at reboot? and what videocard do you have? I'm gonna upload the map to my daughters computer to see if I can see them in there with an old geforce II  MMX card.

I fixed the textures in the arches, it just didnt look right made out of a single square cylinder or regular brushes, now they look F-I-N-E :-) It was a little easier with GtkRadiant than I thought, I never use it, I like Radiant build 2.02 better, but I use Gtk sometimes to run Bob's tools etc.

I guess you can use the email on my profile, or my real one, oliv334@bellsouth.net  thanks!

Maybe now that I'm (hopefully) done tinkering inside my case I can get back to work on all of this.

I'll tinker with the shooter, although it seems to have its own mind and pays no attention to what I want it to do. I rather keep the sound, it's kind of a clue as to where a player is, just like picking up armor and stuff, plus I would have no idea how to shut it up :-)