When I first heard of Generations, I was impressed that it was possible and my interest greatly piqued. When I tried it, I found that it was much, much cooler than I expected.
This mod rocks guys.
I particularly like the Strogg arsenal - very well done and very impressive. The Quake arsenal is also pretty cool I think, but maybe Karen is right that the normal shotgun looks a bit wimpy.
I've got mixed feeling with the majority of the Doom weapons however (the chaingun is awesome though), but that's to be expected for a Doom fanatic like me and I don't expect them to be improved either (I mean, why should you?).
Specifics are the shotguns and the plasma weapons: The shotguns look far too old-fashioned for my tastes, they even look older and more primitive than the original ones imo - at least the brown areas didn't look exactly like wood (more like some sort of plastic material that was painted brown) in the classic Doom game.
The plasma rifle looks too "shiny" with those plasma tubes (which is the same issue I had with the Q3A plasma rifle) - I just don't think a believable weapon would have such a large source of light, plus I liked the original brown coating of the original better.
The BFG looks like a big plastic toy gun and seems much too broad imho (compare it to the Strogg BFG 10K).
But those small issues with weapons looks are completely obliterated in the light of everything else which just plain rocks - great work guys.
Looking forward to seeing animated weapons in the upcoming versions
