2024-03-29, 15:13 *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
  Print  
Author Topic: Passion of the Christ? (eh)  (Read 16827 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Hedhunta
 
Chton
*******
Posts: 231

« on: 2004-02-26, 03:23 »

...havent seen it yet.. but I have some comments on the stupid hype its getting:

1, why is it.. all of a sudden, all these christians see this movie, and all of a sudden they think their 'better christians' (exact quote from an interview on tv, yes i know.. media spun.. but) ... after having seen it..  is it that their just too lazy to actually read the bible? or is it they are only what i call  'convenient christians' .. christians that are only that, when its convenient for them

2, anti semetic, this one really chafes me, it may or may not be anti semetic, but why is that all of a sudden a ticket to criticize the movie when its supposed to be a realistic movie? If we go by history, that its completely true! this is like saying we cant watch WW2 movies because the Nazis put the jews in concentration camps

3, Violence.. uhm, i havent seen it.. but regardless.. i dont see how this movie can be anymore violent than SPR, Gladiator, or the like, but as soon as they slap the name Christ on it it becomes too violent?  ......this opinion may change after i SEE it.. but still.


*eagerly awaits Pho's response.. fun reading Slipgate - Smile
Logged
Angst
Rabid Doomer
 

Team Member
Elite
***
Posts: 1011

WWW
« Reply #1 on: 2004-02-26, 03:39 »

All 3 of those can be answered simply:
Most Christians, aren't.
Logged

"Who says a chainsaw isn't a ranged weapon?"
MantiCore
 
Cacodemon
****
Posts: 70

« Reply #2 on: 2004-02-26, 04:56 »

My take:
(Note: I am not a religious person and my main reason for seeing the film is because of the positive reviews i've read of it thus far and of course all the hype and controversy)


The Passion is an incredibly powerful film. Its repulsive, disgusting, uplifting and wonderful all at the same time. (and if it wern't religious it would've been an NC-17, easy).

The film works on many different levels, the only problem I had with it being the scenes where Jesus is bringing the cross to the hill. That scene dragged on FOREVER. That scene aside, I really enjoyed everything about the film. From the bizarre visuals of Satan and the subplot of Judas and Peter to the hard-to-watch torture scenes. Its all done without flaw.

If it wouldn't have been for that cross dragging scene dragging on far too long, this would have been a 4 star movie to me, as it stands, its a 3.5.


The film is all around gorgous, the cinematography and lighting being some of the best i've seen in a film in the past ten years. From the ominouss dark blue backdrop of night in the beginning to the bleak, washed out feilds at the end, the film has a great atmosphere.

The music was good, not distracting, but well implemented when used.

Recommended

Logged
Phoenix
Bird of Fire
 

Team Member
Elite (7.5k+)
*********
Posts: 8805

WWW
« Reply #3 on: 2004-02-26, 06:24 »

WORD OF WARNING


This thread will NOT be a forum for posting anti-Christian, anti-Semitic, or any other anti-religious rhetoric.  Please keep it on topic.  If you don't like the movie, that's fine, say why, but NO BASHING of any kind will be tolerated on this thread.  Any replies that seek to:

1)  Blame Christianity and/or religion for all the worlds evils
2)  Attack Christianity and/or any other religion
3)  Attack any individual(s) for their beliefs (or lack thereof)

Will be subsequently deleted.
 NO FLAMING.  If you can't have a reasonable discussion about this topid, then don't post here.  The usual parties know who they are in this respect.  NO POLITICS.  I'm tired of any topic that involves a religious subject turning political.  Keep it on topic please.

That being said, let's move on.


Quote from: Hedhunta
...havent seen it yet.. but I have some comments on the stupid hype its getting:

Well, I've not seen it yet myself.  I'm going to wait for the theatres to become a little less busy.  I have been keeping track of the movie for some time now though, on and off.  I'll try to answer your questions as best as I can. Slipgate - Smile

Quote
1, why is it.. all of a sudden, all these christians see this movie, and all of a sudden they think their 'better christians' (exact quote from an interview on tv, yes i know.. media spun.. but) ... after having seen it..  is it that their just too lazy to actually read the bible? or is it they are only what i call  'convenient christians' .. christians that are only that, when its convenient for them

The answer there is two-fold.  Most movies that depict what Christ went through in his final hours are, shall we say, "family friendly".  Here's what the prophet Isiah had to say:

Isaiah 52:14:"... His visage was so marred more than any man, and his form more than the sons of men"

I'm sure you've heard the term "beaten beyond recognition" ?  He was beaten so badly that he could not be recognized as HUMAN.  Most people cannot contemplate this kind of torture.  Most Christians don't like to think unhappy thoughts.  Seeing something like this gives them a very visceral experience.  It's one thing to say "He was whipped and nailed to a cross".  It's another thing to watch it happen.  As a Christian, you are humbled and you begin to apreciate just what your God went through to buy your salvation.

As far as the "luke-warm" Christians, God has this to say about them in Revelation:  

Revelation 3:15 - 18:  I know thy works, that thou art neither cold nor hot: I would thou wert cold or hot.  So then because thou art lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will spew thee out of my mouth.  Because thou sayest, I am rich, and increased with goods, and have need of nothing; and knowest not that thou art wretched, and miserable, and poor, and blind, and naked:  I counsel thee to buy of me gold tried in the fire, that thou mayest be rich; and white raiment, that thou mayest be clothed, and that the shame of thy nakedness do not appear; and anoint thine eyes with eyesalve, that thou mayest see.

Basically what's being said is "You're wishy-washy.  You won't commit to your faith, you just play at it.  I'll reject you for this.  You're more focused on money and material things, and are blind to the fact that you're spiritually empty.  Quit pretending!  Wake up and see yourselves for what you are, then straighten yourselves out and get with the program."

A lot of people who go through the motions, go to church or mass, and don't really live according to the Word are getting a wake-up call when they go to see this.  How many will actually take it to heart, well, who knows.


Quote
2, anti semetic, this one really chafes me, it may or may not be anti semetic, but why is that all of a sudden a ticket to criticize the movie when its supposed to be a realistic movie? If we go by history, that its completely true! this is like saying we cant watch WW2 movies because the Nazis put the jews in concentration camps

The only people claiming it's anti-Semetic is the ADL so far as I've checked.  A lot of the people working on the film ARE JEWISH.  What nationality was Jesus's mother, by the way?  She was Jewish.  How can it be anti-Semetic?  From what I've seen the  people criticizing the film are squawking because they say it makes it look like the Jews - not the Romans - were responsible for Christ's death.

As a rule, I don't preach on the boards, but this is an area I need to correct.  If you are a Christian, and believe the bible, then Christ crucified Christ.  How does that work you say?  Jesus offered himself as a sacrifice for the sins of man.  He chose to die.  He did not have to.  How?  

St. John 18:10-11: Then Simon Peter  having a sword drew it, and smote the ear of the high priest's servant, and cut off his right ear.  The servant's name was Malchus.  Then said Jesus unto Peter, "Put up thy sword into thy sheath:  the cup which my Father hath given me, shall I not drink it?"

Also in St. Matthew 26:51-56:  And, behold, one of them which were with Jesus stretched out his hand, and drew his sword, and struck a servant of the high priest's, and smote off his ear.  Then said Jesus unto him, "Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword.  Thinkest thou that I cannot now pray to my Father, and he shall presently give me more than twelve Legions of angels?  But how then shall the scriptures be fulfilled, that thus it must be?"  In that same hour said Jesus to the multitudes, "Are ye come out as against a thief with swords and staves for to take me? I sat daily with you teaching in the temple, and ye laid no hold on me.  But all this was done, that the scriptures of the prophets might be fulfilled." Then all the disciples forsook him, and fled.

So in this sense Christ new exactly what was happening.  He could have stopped it if he wanted to.  As a Christian, it is wrong to place blame on the Jews OR the Romans for the crucifixion.  This was a gift from God to man, not a martyrdom.  There is a big difference.  A lot of people, even so-called Christians, do not understand this.  Lack of understanding is usually the breeding ground for blame and hatred.  Christians, well, except us birds, are still human after all, and nobody is perfect.  This is why educating yourself is crucial, and being slow to rise to judgement of others is always a good idea too.


Quote
3, Violence.. uhm, i havent seen it.. but regardless.. i dont see how this movie can be anymore violent than SPR, Gladiator, or the like, but as soon as they slap the name Christ on it it becomes too violent?  ......this opinion may change after i SEE it.. but still.

Well, this is where we get back to the "Christian themes can't be violent" problem.  The bible is FULL of violence.  In the Old Testament you have God saying to the jews "Go thee forth and slay".  They wiped out entire cultures.  Jesus said "turn the other cheek" to his disciples, but to ignore violence is to ignore a great deal of the bible.  Being a Christian also doesn't mean you have to be a goody-little-two-shoes and behave like the Cleavers.  Jesus got violent.  Want to hear?

Matthew 21:12-13: And Jesus went into the temple of God, and cast out all them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the moneychangers, and the seats of them that sold doves, And said unto them, "It is written, My house shall be called the house of prayer; but ye have made it a den of thieves."

People get this idea of Christ as some kind of flower-child with dreamy eyes and Ghandi-like behavior.  Can you imagine Christ being stark-raving mad, running around, hollering, whipping, and chasing people out of the temple, knocking over their tables?  This place was supposed to be a holy place, and here people were selling animals and changing money, and he was absolutely furious.  Ever see those "What would Jesus Do?" T-shirts?  Think of what Jesus did when he felt righteously angry.  Being a Christian does NOT mean you have to be a sissy or a wimp.  It does mean that you have to give account for your actions, but debating the apropriateness of the application of forceful response for a Christian is beyond the scope of this thread.

Anyway, those are my answers.  I hope they're satisfactory.
Logged


I fly into the night, on wings of fire burning bright...
Devlar
 
Makron
********
Posts: 398

WWW
« Reply #4 on: 2004-02-26, 06:32 »

I am virilantly anti-religion, its fairly obvious to see that from the tirades I go on around here

That being said, the prinicipal of Freedom of Speech works on the assumption that you will allow something to be seen and heard even if you disagree with it

All of this stupidity about anti-semitism and violence is of little consequence. Honestly, I don't know why you hear such an uproar against a film that's based on a book that largely is anti-semetic yet you hear very little critique of the book itself but only of the film. Also why do we not hear that the movie is anti-Italian? Since even if the heads of the jewish establishment weaved a plot to kill Jesus, it was a Roman who finally speared him.

Another fine episode of "you have the right to be offended"

Oh and Phoenix, religion is politics
Logged
Phoenix
Bird of Fire
 

Team Member
Elite (7.5k+)
*********
Posts: 8805

WWW
« Reply #5 on: 2004-02-26, 07:02 »

Quote from: Devlar
Honestly, I don't know why you hear such an uproar against a film that's based on a book that largely is anti-semetic yet you hear very little critique of the book itself but only of the film.
I find that a very interesting comment, considering over half the bible (the entire Old Testament) was written by Jews, Jesus WAS a Jew, and so were his disciples.

As for the statement about religion being politics, I am not exactly sure of your intentions, but please do not use that declaration as a logic attempt to try to worm around the warning I've stated above.  There are no constitutional rights on the Wirehead board.  Freedom of speech is at the discretion of those in charge of the forums.  Moderators are the gods here, and if this goes off topic or someone attempts to take over the topic I'll invoke a little divine intervention. Slipgate - Smile
Logged


I fly into the night, on wings of fire burning bright...
Lilazzkicker
 

Beta Tester
Quad God
**********
Posts: 571

WWW
« Reply #6 on: 2004-02-26, 07:09 »

I am in total aggrement with Phoenix on the above mentioned.  This thread will stay on topic, for a change, unlike some other topics, it will not turn into a bashing thread like so many before it, I know the general consensus on this subject.  As do many others, this will be enforced, if you force me to mod it, its up to you.
« Last Edit: 2004-02-26, 07:13 by Phoenix » Logged
Devlar
 
Makron
********
Posts: 398

WWW
« Reply #7 on: 2004-02-26, 07:38 »

Quote
I find that a very interesting comment, considering over half the bible (the entire Old Testament) was written by Jews, Jesus WAS a Jew, and so were his disciples.

What I meant is the uproar centers around the fact that Jews are not shown in a very good light in the movie, but then so what? they aren't shown in a very good light in the book either (well the Jews that remain Jewish), yet there is no uproar against the New Testament. That is what I meant. Converting the accounts of a book to a movie yet only attacking the movie as anti-semetic but not the book itself is a rather interesting phenomenon that makes you go "hmm"

Yes Lilazzkicker, I'm sure Phoenix needs your moral support
Logged
Phoenix
Bird of Fire
 

Team Member
Elite (7.5k+)
*********
Posts: 8805

WWW
« Reply #8 on: 2004-02-26, 07:52 »

Nice dig there, Devlar. Having a Beer

Personally I think there's enough attacking in the world as it is.  Besides, there's plenty of people who attack the bible regularly, especially in the more intellectually elite circles.  Oobey views it as a work of fiction himself, although I must admit, we do get along just fine, and can have rational discussions about religion and science.  I don't understand why some people feel they shouldn't.  But then, understanding is what this movie is all about.  And we ARE talking about the movie in this thread.  Slipgate - Smile
Logged


I fly into the night, on wings of fire burning bright...
OoBeY
 
Hans Grosse
*******
Posts: 299

« Reply #9 on: 2004-02-26, 08:00 »

Phoenix, Devlar, all of wirehead... I come to you as a changed man. Before I saw this film, I admit I was full of hatred and malice towards Jesus Christ, Savior of Mankind. I never understood the suffering that our Lord went through to forgive us for our sins, and lead us from eternal damnation.

Phoenix, I would like to apologize for any cynicism I held towards you or your teachings before. I admit I was not fully prepared to see them, but now that I have seen the light deep within them, I ask if you can forgive me, and accept me as one of your own.

But more importantly... Devlar, like you, I once hated religion for many reasons, reasons I had convinced myself were true. But now... now I must ask you to look deep within yourself. Like I once did, you have a built a cold callous shell towards the outside world, but even you cannot deny there is something that is tearing at you, saying that this isn't right. Devlar, that is the voice of Christ. Through your hatemongering, you are leading yourself down a path of eternal damnation, and an existence defined by pain and suffering. Ask yourself, child, if this is really the path you wish for yourself in the eternal afterlife. I implore you to see this film, and reevaluate your life, and the path you're going down. I ask this not for my sake, but for yours.

May the Lord Jesus Christ be with you at all times.
Logged
Devlar
 
Makron
********
Posts: 398

WWW
« Reply #10 on: 2004-02-26, 08:02 »

Well, I have nothing against the bible itself as a piece of writing, its a great story even I will admit that with some great lessons to pull out from it. I have a far greater problem with people who feed others the bits and parts in order to elicit a desired response.

Back to the movie though, I'm going to go see it on the weekend, mainly as a treat to my mother who is a catholic. I'm sure it'll be brutal, I'm sure it'll descriminate, but honestly it'll most likely be a far nicer picture than what was in my head the first time I read the book.

EDIT:
Quote
I implore you to see this film, and reevaluate your life, and the path you're going down. I ask this not for my sake, but for yours.

I'm okay with what I'm doing. I might take a job offer to go record human rights abuses in Chechnya for a year. I'm okay with where I'm going. If this means hell, and I am to be whipped for all eternity, that's okay too. At least in my mind, when I go I go free and without strings. Oh I love the sarcasm Slipgate - Grin

Honestly, who thought Braveheart was anti-British?
« Last Edit: 2004-02-26, 08:18 by Devlar » Logged
OoBeY
 
Hans Grosse
*******
Posts: 299

« Reply #11 on: 2004-02-26, 09:09 »

People are no fun when they don't take your bait.  Slipgate - Wink
Logged
Devlar
 
Makron
********
Posts: 398

WWW
« Reply #12 on: 2004-02-26, 09:12 »

The worm actually has to look like a worm first, so in the grandeur of monty python "Your not fooling anyone you know?"
Logged
games keeper
 

Elite
*
Posts: 1375

« Reply #13 on: 2004-02-26, 17:52 »

I'm a christian ,  type 1) byt the way , or atleast the last 2 sentences , I dont have a problem with hedhuntas post  :unsure:
Logged
Kain-Xavier
 

Beta Tester
Icon of Sin
***********
Posts: 917

« Reply #14 on: 2004-02-26, 18:40 »

Well, I'll probably wait for this one to come out on DVD or VHS before I see it.  It sounds really interesting, and I'm looking forward to seeing it, but I rarely go out to see a movie in the theaters unless it's one that  I've been waiting for a long time.   I do not mean that in a derogatory manner either.  The last movie I saw in theaters was the Matrix Revolutions.  The last one before that was Terminator 3 I believe.  I'd just rather play games in my spare time as I get more bang for the buck. Slipgate - Tongue
Logged

Hedhunta
 
Chton
*******
Posts: 231

« Reply #15 on: 2004-02-26, 19:06 »

Pho: thank you.. just skimmed your reading, but it looks good so far..  and i did not intend to start a flame war, i just wanted to vent my concern on the hype the movie is getting..  not that i do or do not like the movie.. once ive seen it i will say that.
Logged
ConfusedUs
 

Elite (2k+)
**
Posts: 2358

WWW
« Reply #16 on: 2004-02-26, 19:21 »

Apparently it's so emotional it causes heart attacks!
http://www.cnn.com/2004/US/Central/02/26/p...reut/index.html
Logged
Phoenix
Bird of Fire
 

Team Member
Elite (7.5k+)
*********
Posts: 8805

WWW
« Reply #17 on: 2004-02-27, 06:51 »

Hed:  No problem.  We're  trying to keep this discusion just that - a discussion.  I don't want a flame war anymore than you do.  If you want to bring up a topic for discussion then I feel you have a  right to do so without  having to worry about a flame war resulting.  That's why we have moderators - to keep the board civil, even if controversial. Slipgate - Smile
Logged


I fly into the night, on wings of fire burning bright...
McDeth
 

Makron
********
Posts: 388

Wildly Inappropriate

« Reply #18 on: 2004-02-27, 06:59 »

Life of Brian was good...anyone see that?
Logged

Beer? I'm down.
Woodsman
Icon of Booze
 

Beta Tester
Icon of Sin
***********
Posts: 823

« Reply #19 on: 2004-02-27, 07:26 »

im sure the film does depict individual  jews as responsible for death of christ but saying that makes it anti semetic is like me saying me saying RTCW is anti german. Really  lets stop being whiney bitches.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3
  Print  
 
Jump to: